Music Articles
1:46 pm
Mon July 7, 2014

Billy Eckstine: A Crooner Who Crossed Barriers

Originally published on Mon July 7, 2014 5:56 pm

Billy Eckstine was smooth as silk. He was tall and handsome, sported a pencil-thin mustache and sang in a distinctive baritone.

"I consider Billy Eckstine the Jackie Robinson of popular music," says Cary Ginell, author of Mr. B: The Music and Life of Billy Eckstine. "Before Billy Eckstine came along, blacks, they would either sing blues or they would be in jazz bands, or they would sing in vocal groups, like The Mills Brothers or The Ink Spots. Or as a novelty singer. But they were not permitted to enter the domain of Perry Como and Bing Crosby. And Eckstine was the first one to successfully do that."

Eckstine began singing as a child. He was born in Pittsburgh 100 years ago this week. His family moved to Washington, where he attended Howard University. But after winning an amateur talent contest, he left college to begin his professional career.

By the mid-1930s, he was singing for the popular Earl "Fatha" Hines orchestra. Along with his vocals, Eckstine played trumpet in the Hines orchestra, and he was interested in the new sound some of his bandmates were experimenting with in late night jam sessions. In 1943, he left Hines to form his own band.

"When I had my band," Eckstine said, "we were pioneering that sound, but they weren't big names. They were just guys starting out."

They were Charlie Parker and Dizzy Gillespie and, later, Art Blakey and Miles Davis. Eckstine fronted the first bebop orchestra. In 1984, between sets in his dressing room at the Blue Note in New York, Eckstine told me he was proud of the music his band made, but not the name critics gave it.

"And I resent bebop. I resent that name," Eckstine said. "It's progressive jazz is what it was. Bebop was something that was named because a guy wrote it up, and wrote it up like that. So they start calling the music bebop, which sounds comedic to me. And it was anything but comedic. It was very studied music."

But the band, with its innovations in rhythm and harmony, was ahead of its time.

"It wasn't commercial," Eckstine said. "Wrong time. Too new. And then a lot of your so-called 'critics' who were supposed to be authorities on what we were doing didn't know what we were doing. So therefore, every time we played somewhere, we'd get bum rapped. So why butt your head against the wall on something like that?"

So Eckstine moved to a solo career singing popular ballads. Ginell says Eckstine's popularity rivaled Frank Sinatra's.

Eckstine "was recording million-selling records for MGM," Ginell says. "He was mobbed by teenage girls wherever he went. He really was a matinee idol, so to speak, in the recording industry, and had his eyes on proceeding into film and television as well in the 1950s."

And then, all at once, Eckstine's future as a crossover media star was cut short by a single photo in a LIFE Magazine profile in April, 1950.

"The profile featured a photograph of Eckstine coming out of a nightclub in New York City, and being mobbed by white teenage girls," Ginell says. "If you look at the photograph, it looks very innocuous and very innocent. It's actually what America should be like, with no racial tension, no racial separation — just honest love and happiness between the races. But America wasn't ready for that in 1950. White America did not want Billy Eckstine dating their daughters."

Eckstine continued to record and perform, but white disc jockeys would not play his records on segregated stations.

"Maybe black male singers are not supposed to sing about love," Eckstine said. "You're supposed to sing about hurt. You know, maybe that's what they got their hang-up in. So I just think it was the times. At that time the black male was very stepped on."

But Eckstine insisted he was never bitter.

"I'm not bitter about anything," he said. "No, because to be bitter is a waste of time when you should be doing something constructive. You never get old doing something you like to do. And this is something I like to do. No hard job. If you look out in the audience, see smiling people, you're bringing happiness to somebody. How many people have that privilege?"

Billy Eckstine continued to bring happiness to his fans performing in clubs and casinos until his death in 1993.

Copyright 2014 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

He was called the Sepia Sinatra - the Bronze Balladeer. As a crooner, Billy Eckstein sold millions of records in the years following the Second World War. As a bandleader, he helped usher in a new era of modern jazz. Billy Eckstein was born 100 years ago tomorrow. Tom Vitale has his story.

TOM VITALE, BYLINE: Billy Eckstein was smooth as silk. He was tall and handsome. He sported a pencil-thin mustache. And he sang in a distinctive baritone.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "I APOLOGIZE")

BILLY ECKSTEIN: (Singing) If I told a lie - if I made you cry, when I said goodbye, I'm sorry.

CARY GINELL: I consider Billy Eckstein the Jackie Robinson of popular music.

VITALE: Cary Ginell is author of "Mr. B.: The Music And Life of Billy Eckstein."

GINELL: Before Billy Eckstein came along, blacks - they would either sing blues or they would be in jazz bands or they would sing in vocal groups, like the Mills Brothers or the Ink Spots. But they were not permitted to enter the domain of Perry Como and Bing Crosby. And Eckstein was the first one to successfully do that.

VITALE: Eckstein began singing as a child. He was born in Pittsburgh. His family moved to Washington, D.C., where he attended Howard University. But after winning an amateur talent contest, he left college to begin his professional career. By in the mid-1930s, he was singing for the popular Earl Fatha Hines orchestra.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "JELLY, JELLY")

ECKSTEIN: (Singing) Jelly, jelly, jelly - jelly stains on my mind.

VITALE: Along with his vocals, Eckstein played trumpet in Hines orchestra. And he was interested in the new sound some of his band mates were experiencing with in the late-night jam sessions. In 1943, he left Hines to form his own band.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

ECKSTEIN: We were pioneering that sound. But they weren't big names. They were just guys starting out.

VITALE: They were Charlie Parker and Dizzy Gillespie and later, Art Blakey and Miles Davis. Eckstein fronted the first Bebop Orchestra. In 1984, between sets in his dressing room at the Blue Note in New York, he told me he was proud of the music his band made but not the name critics gave it.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

ECKSTEIN: I resent Bebop. I resent that name. It's progressive jazz is what it was. Bebop sounds comedic to me. And it was anything but comedic. It was very steady music.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "RHYTHM IN A RIFF")

ECKSTEIN: (Scatting).

VITALE: But the band, with its innovations in rhythm and harmony, was ahead of its time.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

ECKSTEIN: It wasn't commercial. It was too new. A lot of your so-called critics, who were supposed to be authorities on what we were doing, didn't know what we were doing. And so every time we'd play somewhere, we'd get bum rapped. You know, why butt your head on the wall.

VITALE: So Billy Eckstein moved to a solo career, singing popular ballads.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "FOOLS RUSH IN")

ECKSTEIN: (Singing) Fools rush in, where angels fear to tread. And so I come to you, my love - my heart above my head.

VITALE: Biographer Cary Ginell says Eckstein's popularity rivaled Frank Sinatra's.

GINELL: He was recording millions - selling records for MGM. He was mobbed by teenage girls wherever he went. He really was a matinee idol, so to speak, in the recording industry. And had his eyes on proceeding into film and television, as well.

VITALE: And then all at once, in April 1950, Eckstein's future as a crossover media star was cut short by a single photo in a Life magazine profile.

GINELL: The profile featured a photograph of Eckstein coming out of a nightclub in New York City and being mobbed by white teenage girls. It looks very innocuous and very innocent. It's actually what America should be like with no racial tension, no racial separation. But America wasn't ready for that in 1950. White America did not want Billy Eckstein dating their daughters.

VITALE: Eckstein continued to record and perform. But white disc jockeys would not play his records on segregated stations.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

ECKSTEIN: Maybe black singers - black male singers are not supposed to sing about love. You're supposed to sing about hurt. Maybe that's what they got their hang-up in.

VITALE: But Eckstein insisted he was never bitter.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

ECKSTEIN: To be bitter is waste of time, when you should be doing something constructive. You never get old doing something you like to do. And this is something I like to do. I mean, if you look out in the audience, you see smiling people, you bringing happiness to somebody. How many people have that privilege?

VITALE: Billy Eckstein continued to bring happiness to his fans, performing in clubs and casinos until his death in 1993. For NPR News, I'm Tom's Vitale in New York.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "STORMY MONDAY BLUES")

ECKSTEIN: It's gone and started raining. I'm lonesome as a man can be. It's gone and started raining.

SIEGEL: You're listening to ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.